Distinguishing Question Subjectivity from Difficulty for Improved Crowdsourcing


Yuan Jin, Mark Carman, Ye Zhu, Wray Buntine ;
Proceedings of The 10th Asian Conference on Machine Learning, PMLR 95:192-207, 2018.


The questions in a crowdsourcing task typically exhibit varying degrees of difficulty and subjectivity. Their joint effects give rise to the variation in responses to the same question by different crowd-workers. This variation is low when the question is easy to answer and objective, and high when it is difficult and subjective. Unfortunately, current quality control methods for crowdsourcing consider only the question difficulty to account for the variation. As a result, these methods cannot distinguish workers' ,personal preferences for different correct answers of a partially subjective question from their ability to avoid objectively incorrect answers for that question. To address this issue, we present a probabilistic model which (i) explicitly encodes question difficulty as a model parameter and (ii) implicitly encodes question subjectivity via latent preference factors for crowd-workers. We show that question subjectivity induces grouping of crowd-workers, revealed through clustering of their latent preferences. Moreover, we develop a quantitative measure for the question subjectivity. Experiments show that our model (1) improves both the question true answer prediction and the unseen worker response prediction, and (2) can potentially provide rankings of questions coherent with human assessment in terms of difficulty and subjectivity.

Related Material